Gas Generator vs Diesel Generator – A Comparison

In our article on a recent gas generator installation the S&A team were involved in, we briefly discuss the numerous benefits of upgrading your diesel gen-set to a gas generator system. Don’t get us wrong, ‘old faithful’ diesel generators are far from losing their long-standing place in the backup power sector.

Diesel generators has long been the standard, but as international interest into green energy solutions heightens, we’re seeing a growth in gas powered generators’ popularity. This leaves countless people with a dilemma when first looking into establishing back-up power for their home or business. Diesel generator or gas generator? Tried-and-trusted or cutting-edge?

This article offers pros and cons of both types of generators, and shares how S&A Generators can assist with any of your generator-related needs:

A (very) short comparison of the two

Noise pollution is something nobody enjoys, which makes diesel generators somewhat of a bad choice for eco-estates and other residential settings. On the other hand, natural gas is pretty explosive, and requires specialist care when being handled.

CD & Power, international backup power providers, summarise the differences between diesel generators and gas generators pretty well:

  • DIESEL GENSET = inexpensive and reliable, but loud and sometimes messy
  • NATURAL GAS GENSET = quiet and cleaner, but usually expensive and temperamental

Pros & cons of diesel and gas generators

It must be noted that continuous innovation in the field has brought much of the above into question. Diesel generators are becoming quieter and more fuel efficient, while gas powered generators are getting more cost-effective and robust. Nevertheless, here are the most common arguments for and against diesel and natural gas generators:

Diesel Generators:

  • Sturdy, reliable, and have a long lifespan when correctly maintained.
  • Diesel is less flammable, so considered safer to use as a fuel source.
  • More portable, so more versatile in terms of application.
  • Range in sizes from very small (residential) to large (industrial).
  • Louder than gas generators when in operation.
  • Price to keep fuelled fluctuates with diesel prices.
  • Requires storage capability to keep fuel on site.

Gas Generators:

  • Natural gas is cleaner, with lower emissions, than fossil fuels.
  • Gas generators are much quieter than their diesel counterparts.
  • They often come in at a fraction of the cost.
  • It costs less to maintain a natural gas generator.
  • A gas generator has a shorter lifespan.
  • Much larger than most diesel generators.
  • Gas is explosive, so extra care must be taken.

Have your generator installed by the best

S&A Generators has been involved with backup power installations and maintenance since before gas generators were even a thing. We’ve seen the sector innovate and improve, and we’ve done so alongside it. Our teams are able to source, transport, and install diesel and gas generators. We also offer generator maintenance services in KwaZulu-Natal. For any and all of your diesel or gas generator needs, get in touch with us here.

Manuals

Download our Manuals for any specific installation or generator specs

An image respresenting 8 Signs You Need A Diesel Generator Mechanic

8 Signs You Need A Diesel Generator Mechanic

Like all internal combustion engines, there’s a lot that can go wrong with a diesel generator’s...
how much does a generator cost?

7 Factors That Impact A Generator’s Price

Cost of raw materials used in its manufacture Operating costs of the manufacturer Fluctuating...
An image respresenting Choosing the Right Generators for Your Building

Choosing the Right Generators for Your Building

How do you go about choosing the right generator? With load shedding still a very real risk in...
Electrical power cables connecting to electrical equipment - Will using a generator damage my electrical equipment?

Will using a generator damage my electrical equipment?

It’s something many home owners and business owners are investing in, but with so many on the...
An image respresenting First-Time Buyers' Guide For Generators

First-Time Buyers’ Guide For Generators

With the ongoing challenges of load shedding in South Africa, many business owners are considering...
An image respresenting Why Generators Are Basically Portable Power Stations

Why Generators Are Basically Portable Power Stations

Power stations are those little brick buildings with steel doors you see at the entrance to any...
An image respresenting The Role of Diesel Generators in Hybrid Energy Systems

The Role of Diesel Generators in Hybrid Energy Systems

If you've followed energy news in South Africa over the past decade, you'll know that loadshedding...
An image respresenting Can You Run A Generator Continuously?

Can You Run A Generator Continuously?

Loadshedding has become a frustrating reality that's here to stay for the foreseeable future. But...

Recent Posts